How to Choose a Life Insurance Beneficiary: Complete Guide

How to Choose a Life Insurance Beneficiary: Complete Guide
Bellevue Assurance TeamJanuary 5, 20247 min readLife Insurance
beneficiariesestate planninglife insurance basicslegal

What is a Life Insurance Beneficiary?

A life insurance beneficiary is the person, people, or entity you designate to receive your policy's death benefit when you pass away. Whether you have term life insurance, final expense insurance, or another type of coverage, naming the right beneficiaries is essential. Choosing your beneficiaries is one of the most important decisions you'll make when purchasing life insurance.

While it may seem straightforward, there are important considerations and potential pitfalls to avoid.

Primary vs. Contingent Beneficiaries

Primary Beneficiaries

Your primary beneficiaries are the first in line to receive the death benefit. You can name multiple primary beneficiaries and specify what percentage each should receive.

Example:

  • Spouse: 50%
  • Adult Child 1: 25%
  • Adult Child 2: 25%

Contingent Beneficiaries

Contingent beneficiaries (also called secondary beneficiaries) only receive the death benefit if all primary beneficiaries have predeceased you or are unable to claim the benefit.

Think of contingent beneficiaries as your backup plan.

Who Can You Name as a Beneficiary?

You can name almost anyone or any entity as your beneficiary:

  • Individuals: Spouse, children, parents, siblings, friends, domestic partners
  • Organizations: Charities, non-profits, religious organizations
  • Trusts: A trust you've established
  • Your estate: Though this is generally not recommended (see below)

Minor Children as Beneficiaries

You can name minor children as beneficiaries, but there are complications:

  • Minors cannot directly receive insurance proceeds
  • A court-appointed guardian or trust may be required to manage the funds
  • This can delay payout and create legal costs

Better Option: Create a trust or name a trusted adult guardian as beneficiary to manage funds for your children.

Common Beneficiary Mistakes to Avoid

1. Naming Your Estate as Beneficiary

Why it's problematic:

  • Proceeds become subject to probate (expensive and time-consuming)
  • Money can be claimed by creditors
  • Distribution is delayed while estate is settled
  • No privacy - becomes part of public record

Better approach: Name specific individuals or a trust

2. Forgetting to Update After Life Changes

Life events that should trigger a beneficiary review:

  • Marriage or divorce
  • Birth or adoption of children
  • Death of a beneficiary
  • Changes in financial circumstances
  • Falling out with a named beneficiary

Failing to update beneficiaries is one of the most common mistakes. Your ex-spouse could receive your death benefit if you forget to update after divorce.

3. Not Naming Contingent Beneficiaries

If your primary beneficiary predeceases you and you haven't named a contingent beneficiary, the death benefit may go to your estate (see problem #1 above).

4. Being Too Vague

Avoid vague designations like "my children" without specifics. What if you have more children later? What if one child predeceases you?

Be specific: Name individuals with identifying information (full name, date of birth, relationship)

5. Not Coordinating with Your Will

Your life insurance beneficiary designation overrides your will. Even if your will says everything goes to your spouse, if your beneficiary designation says your brother, the insurance proceeds go to your brother.

Special Situations to Consider

Blended Families

If you have children from a previous marriage and a current spouse, consider:

  • Using a trust to ensure both spouse and children are provided for
  • Clearly specifying percentages to each party
  • Discussing your plans with all parties to avoid surprises

Beneficiaries with Special Needs

If your beneficiary receives government benefits (SSI, Medicaid), a direct inheritance could disqualify them from these programs.

Solution: Establish a Special Needs Trust as the beneficiary to preserve their eligibility while providing financial support.

Pet Care

While you cannot name pets as direct beneficiaries, you can:

  • Name a trusted person with the understanding they'll care for your pet
  • Set up a pet trust
  • Leave funds to an animal welfare organization

Tax Considerations

Good news: Life insurance death benefits are generally not subject to federal income tax for beneficiaries.

However, there are exceptions:

  • If you transfer ownership of your policy within 3 years of death
  • If proceeds are paid to your estate, they may be subject to estate taxes
  • Interest earned on delayed payouts is taxable

Pro tip: For large policies, consult with an estate planning attorney to minimize tax implications.

Per Stirpes vs. Per Capita

When naming multiple beneficiaries, you can specify:

Per Stirpes ("By Branch")

If a beneficiary predeceases you, their share goes to their descendants.

Example: You name your two children as 50/50 beneficiaries. One child predeceases you but has two children. Those grandchildren split their parent's 50% share.

Per Capita ("By Head")

If a beneficiary predeceases you, their share is split equally among surviving beneficiaries.

Example: Same scenario, but the entire death benefit is split 50/50 between your surviving child and the two grandchildren (25% each).

How to Update Your Beneficiaries

  1. Contact your insurance company or agent
  2. Request a change of beneficiary form
  3. Complete the form with full legal names and identifying information
  4. Submit to your insurer - keep a copy for your records
  5. Confirm the change in writing

Do NOT try to change beneficiaries in your will - it won't work. Changes must be made through the insurance company's official process.

Insurance beneficiary form being filled out with pen, showing proper documentation

Beneficiary Checklist

Use this checklist when choosing and reviewing beneficiaries:

  • [ ] Named both primary and contingent beneficiaries
  • [ ] Used full legal names and identifying information
  • [ ] Specified percentages adding up to 100%
  • [ ] Considered using trusts for minor children or special needs beneficiaries
  • [ ] Avoided naming your estate as beneficiary
  • [ ] Reviewed beneficiaries after major life events
  • [ ] Coordinated with overall estate plan
  • [ ] Informed beneficiaries of the policy's existence
  • [ ] Stored policy documents in a safe, accessible place
  • [ ] Set a reminder to review beneficiaries annually

Common Life Events That Require Beneficiary Updates

Marriage

Update your policy within 30-60 days. Consider whether you want your spouse as sole beneficiary or if you'll split between spouse and children from a previous marriage.

Divorce

Critical: Update immediately. Most states don't automatically remove ex-spouses as beneficiaries. Your beneficiary designation supersedes your will.

Birth or Adoption

Add new children and adjust percentages accordingly. Consider setting up a trust rather than naming minor children directly.

Death of Beneficiary

If your primary beneficiary dies, their portion goes to contingent beneficiaries. Review and update to ensure your wishes are clear.

Significant Financial Changes

If beneficiaries' financial situations change dramatically (disability, windfall, bankruptcy), you may want to reconsider designations or use trusts.

Estate planning attorney meeting with couple, discussing beneficiary options and legal documents

Working With Professionals

While you don't need an attorney to name beneficiaries, consider consulting with professionals for:

  • Estate planning attorney: Complex family situations, large policies, estate tax concerns
  • Financial advisor: Coordinating insurance with overall financial plan
  • Tax professional: Understanding tax implications of beneficiary choices
  • Insurance agent: Explaining policy-specific rules and options

Related Articles

Final Thoughts

Choosing life insurance beneficiaries is one of the most important decisions you'll make with your policy. Take time to:

  1. Understand all your options
  2. Consider short and long-term implications
  3. Name contingent beneficiaries
  4. Review designations regularly
  5. Keep records organized and accessible
  6. Communicate your decisions with family when appropriate

Your beneficiary designation is a legal document that supersedes your will. Make sure it accurately reflects your current wishes and family situation.


This article provides general educational information only and should not be considered legal, tax, or financial advice. Beneficiary rules and estate laws vary by state. Consult with qualified legal and tax professionals for advice specific to your situation.

CallEstimateQuote